Calling All Grown-Ups
Arthur Koestler told the story of an old priest he
met during World War II. Fascinated that the man had listened to thousands
of confessions and heard countless
intimate secrets, he asked him what he had learned about human nature.
The priest was naturally reluctant to discuss the secrets of the confessional, even in the most abstract terms. Finally, though, he offered one generalization: Basically, nobody ever grows up.
Amen. When my mother died last June, one of the many emotions that surged through me was an odd feeling of sheer unreadiness. I wanted to say to her, Mom! You cant die yet! I havent finished growing up!
After all, I was only 51.
Koestlers priest never met my mother. She grew up early. I never knew anyone so self-reliant, but so willing to be relied on by others. Until she died, I didnt realize how deeply I felt I still depended on her. That feeling never quite goes away.
One of the fascinating things about celebrity scandals is the sudden revelation, repeated over and over again, that so many famous, powerful, seemingly self-sufficient people have never grown up. What had been the secrets of the diary are thrown onto the front page.
After all, adults are supposed to be making some kind of effort to be responsible and self-sufficient. But many people dont even try to grow up anymore. The low birth rate in modern society suggests that they would rather be children than have them. And the growth of the welfare state is an index of how constantly we are being invited to let others take responsibility for us.
Why do we talk about responsibility in government, when government itself has become a device for shirking and concealing responsibility? The more prosperous we become, the more we hear about poverty and the alleged necessity for the state to take care of those who have been forgotten or left out. Youd think that life were tougher for us than for our ancestors on the farm.
As the state relieves us of responsibility to our parents and children, it increases our responsibilities to itself. You may divorce your spouse, desert (or abort) your children and abandon your parents, but your duty to pay taxes is absolute. There is no divorce or separation from the welfare state, till death do you part (and even then, inheritance taxes will eat up much of your legacy).
Maybe you dont have to support the children youve begotten, but youre going to support other peoples children, and pay their way through college, from coast to coast. The natural ratio of responsibility is askew.
The socialist phenomenon, as Igor Shafarevich has called it, takes many forms and many names. But its a phenomenon of rich societies, not poor ones.
Poor societies cant afford to support a large parasite class; the great majority of people are doomed by necessity to be hard-working peasants. When you have to produce food for your family with your own hands, refusing to take responsibility is not an option.
Its when a society produces a huge surplus of wealth that the parasites multiply and become a powerful force, demanding to be supported and exaggerating their hardships, while politicians, feeling their pain, cater tenderly to their needs. Always at someone elses expense, of course. The fewer the peasants, the more the parasites.
Not coincidentally, rich societies also produce large surpluses of leisured theoreticians to provide rationales for those who wont grow up. A large part of the parasite class is dedicated to education, a luxury that should be privately paid for, though typically advertised as a necessity that must be subsidized. This is why so many intellectuals are on the side of the poor, which in practice always turns out to mean the state.
Frédéric Bastiat wrote that government is organized plunder. It might be added that a politics geared to this kind of government is organized whining.
I suppose we all have an inner child, a whiner and shirker to the end. Nothing wrong with that. But it was one thing to lower the voting age to 18; its another to extend the franchise to the inner child.
|Copyright © 2005 by the Griffin Internet Syndicate,
a division of Griffin Communications
This column may not be reprinted in print or
Internet publications without express permission
of Griffin Internet Syndicate
Archive Table of Contents
Return to the SOBRANS home page.
|FGF E-Package columns by Joe Sobran, Sam Francis, Paul Gottfried, and others are available in a special e-mail subscription provided by the Fitzgerald Griffin Foundation. Click here for more information.|