|Managing Editor /
Ronald N. Neff
President Katrina(Reprinted from SOBRANS, February, page 1)
David Ignatius of the Washington Post quite properly noted that Bush and Dick Cheney make the dubious claim that the presidents constitutional wartime authority trumps everything, even acts of Congress specifically forbidding, say, warrantless wiretaps. Sound familiar? Where have we heard this before?
Yes, of course! Abraham Lincoln felt entitled to claim any powers he deemed necessary to perform his transcendent duty to save the Union. True, the Constitution didnt spell these out, but as Harry V. Jaffa has written, Lincoln discovered a whole reservoir of wartime powers implicit in Article II. Why shouldnt Bush imitate the great example of Lincoln, one of liberalisms gods?
And after all, liberalism adores great presidents, those who, like Lincoln and the Roosevelts, take a creative and expansive view of executive power, not necessarily going by the book. This dovetails nicely with the liberal view of the Constitution as a living document whose meanings evolve over time, adapting to new circumstances.
This is a game any number can play. Today liberals are, by their lights, understandably upset with what Bush is doing, and Im not happy about it myself. But Bush and his men are merely doing what liberals have always done, finding new implications penumbras and emanations and so forth in the Living Document. And they have so many precedents on their side. This is just the Republican version of what the Democrats have been doing since Woodrow Wilson. (And Republicans had been doing it long before that.)
I cant get hysterical about the remote possibility that my own phone may be wiretapped. The real danger is more general than that; and even to call it a danger is wrong, because its a certainty, and its already happening. All limits on Federal power are going the way of the New Orleans levees.
I must admit that the colossal and explosive growth of the Federal Government under Bush has surprised me. But I cant deny its logic, given the legacy of liberalism. What surprises me more painfully is that Bush has done all this with so little protest or resistance from conservatives who should know better.
However it happened, it has happened. The Federal budget first reached a trillion dollars under Ronald Reagan; Bush has now proposed one of $2.77 trillion. And its safe to assume even that figure understates the amount that will actually be spent.
The era of big government is over, Bill Clinton assured us, lying as usual. What we didnt suspect was that Clinton was just the calm before the real storm, to wit, the political Hurricane Katrina that is the Bush administration. Who ever dreamed that a president calling himself a conservative would end any illusion that government could be limited?
Article copyright © 2006 by The Vere Company. All Rights Reserved.
This article may not be reprinted in print or
Internet publications without express permission
of The Vere Company.
Return to the SOBRANS home page.
|SOBRANS and Joe Sobrans columns are available by subscription. Details are available on-line; or call 800-513-5053; or write Fran Griffin.|
|FGF E-Package columns by Joe Sobran, Sam Francis, Paul Gottfried, and others are available in a special e-mail subscription provided by the Fitzgerald Griffin Foundation. Click here for more information.|