SOBRAN'S -- The Real News of the Month August 2001 Volume 8, No. 8 Editor: Joe Sobran Publisher: Fran Griffin (Griffin Communications) Managing Editor: Ronald N. Neff Subscription Rates. Print version: $44.95 per year; $85 for 2 years; trial subscription available for $19.95 (5 issues). E-mail subscriptions: $39.95 for 1 year ($25 with a 12-month subscription to the print edition); $65 for 2 years ($45 with a 2-year subscription to the print edition). Address: SOBRAN'S, P.O. Box 1383, Vienna, VA 22183-1383 Fax: 703-281-6617 Website: www.sobran.com Publisher's Office: 703-255-2211 or www.griffnews.com Foreign Subscriptions (print version only): Add $1.25 per issue for Canada and Mexico; all other foreign countries, add $1.75 per issue. Credit Card Orders: Call 1-800-513-5053. Allow 4-6 weeks for delivery of your first issue CONTENTS Features -> The Moving Picture -> Publisher's Note -> Before the Hive -> For the Record Nuggets (plus Exclusives to this edition) List of Columns Reprinted FEATURES The Moving Picture (page 1) The Hive's big new cause is stem-cell research, as witness a NEWSWEEK cover story posing the issue as "embryo research vs. pro-life politics." Research versus politics -- get it? The story did mention in passing "some 50 groups lobbying for stem-cell research," but that's "science," as opposed to "politics." As usual, the motives of those who want to protect innocent human life are demeaned; those of the killers pass unexamined. * * * Among those who want the federal government to subsidize the killing of live human embryos are, in NEWSWEEK's phrase, "staunch pro-lifers," as in Orrin Hatch (who else?), and that predictable "maverick" John McCain. * * * Seems Roger Clinton took $50,000 from a convicted drug dealer named Gambino on a promise to wangle a presidential pardon, and brother Bill subsequently asked the Justice Department to check Mr. Gambino's eligibility. (No pardon was issued.) He's no kin to us, says New York's famed Gambino family, who are understandably anxious to avoid any impression that they're linked to the Clintons. * * * Jesse "Papa Don't Preach" Jackson keeps appearing on the covers of the tabloids. Enquiring minds want to know: Is he still available for spiritual counseling? * * * Farewell to Carroll O'Connor, 76, forever Archie, our favorite bigot. In spite of the intent of his creator, Norman Lear, Archie won America's sympathy, thanks to O'Connor's brilliant mugging. Archie was in fact a paragon of tolerance, putting up with an insufferable free-loading liberal son-in-law. * * * Farewell also to Mortimer Adler, 98, "the Great Bookie," who promoted the classics for everyman, with special regard for Aristotle and Aquinas. Adler had studied under John Dewey at Columbia, but he rebelled against Dewey's sterile relativism and became a champion of the Good, the True, and the Beautiful. He died a Catholic -- a fact the NEW YORK TIMES saw unfit to print in its obituary. * * * The historian has his own past. Joseph Ellis of Mount Holyoke College, author of prizewinning books on the Founding Fathers, has been exposed as a liar for claiming (among other fabrications) to have seen combat in Vietnam. Ann Coulter points out that during the Clinton impeachment proceedings Ellis also pushed the dubious story that Thomas Jefferson begot a son on his slave Sally Hemings -- lest the public forget that presidential frailty has a long and distinguished pedigree. Publisher's Note (page 2) Dear Subscribers, Have you gotten your copy of the latest booklet of Sobranisms yet? ANYTHING CALLED A "PROGRAM" IS UNCONSTITUTIONAL: CONFESSIONS OF A REACTIONARY UTOPIAN is a collection of about 250 quotations excerpted from past editions of SOBRAN'S. It is small enough to fit in your shirt pocket but packs a wallop of vintage Sobran wit and wisdom. The best news is that it's our gift to you if you renew your subscription. Or you can buy it for the low price of just $5.95 (including postage). Details on how to get it are enclosed. [SEE www.sobran.com/ products.shtml.] We'll also send it along with any gift subscriptions or new subscriptions that you wish to buy. [See http://www.sobran.com/subscrib.shtml.] Can you write a title? If you could write the title of this booklet of Sobran quotations, what would it be? We are conducting a search for the best title for this and future booklets. Send suggestions (along with your name) by mail, fax, or e-mail (the last two being preferred, if possible). See the addresses in the credit box above. If we decide to use *your* title, you will receive an acknowledgment in the book. Letters-to-the-Editor column Periodically we are going to start printing some of your letters in SOBRAN'S. The most likely to be published would be a *short* letter with one question or comment that Joe could respond to. Mail to "Letters to the Editor" at the mailing address or fax number above, or e-mail to joe@sobran.com. Attention Charter Subscriber Wannabes. Our exclusive SOBRAN'S benefactor club of those donors giving $1,000 or more enjoys an annual anniversary luncheon in Washington, D.C. The good news is that you don't necessarily have to pay all at once. For just $83.33 per month (for 12 months), you can become a Charter Subscriber and attend our unique gala affair. This year, the Seventh SOBRAN'S Anniversary Celebration will be held on Saturday, December 8, beginning at 12:30 P.M. The site is the Historic George Town Club, 1530 Wisconsin Ave., N.W. Joe promises to give another sterling speech and the food and company will be exemplary. A flyer with details is enclosed. But you have to be in the distinctive Charter Subscribers' Club to attend, so join today! [See also www.sobran.com/ charter.shtml.] * * * Did you know that Joe's column is syndicated through Griffin Internet Syndicate (www.griffnews.com)? Do you know the opinion page editor of your local newspaper? I need the editor's name *and* e-mail address so that we can e-mail a packet of sample Sobran columns. If you can help, please mail, fax, or e-mail the information to me at griffin@sobran.com. We want to get Joe published in as many newspapers as possible. Finally, don't forget that prayer can move mountains. Since we have mountains to move to get SOBRAN'S to be one of the nation's leading publications, we need your frequent prayers. Perhaps you would consider reading one of the Psalms and offering it as a prayer. The Psalms are filled with hardship and danger, but also with joy and praise in the Lord, as in Psalm 100: "Cry out with joy to the Lord, all the earth. Serve the Lord with gladness.... Indeed how good is the Lord! Eternal is His merciful love. He is faithful from age to age." ---Fran Griffin Before the Hive (pages 3-5) Over the past twenty years I've often written about "the Hive" -- my nickname for the informal body of opinion comprising liberals, socialists, outright Communists, and various other strains of "progressive" opinion. Like an odor, such folk are easier to sense than to define. They include assorted activists for specific causes, as well as more passive enablers, especially in the news media. The Democratic Party is their chief American organ. The Soviet Union, until it collapsed, was the Queen Bee of the Hive. The Worker Bees of the West took their bearings -- though not their orders -- from the great socialist motherland. They operated sympathetically, but independently. Most of them would have felt insulted if their Soviet allies had tried to push them around. The Hive was not, and is not, a conspiracy; it's more a pattern. Naive anti-Communists, seeing the pattern, have mistaken it for a conspiracy. The Bees, on the other hand, have made their own mistake. Knowing that they aren't parties to a conspiracy, they fail to see the evident pattern of their collective behavior. By sheer, insectlike instinct, they obey not the dictates of a foreign power, but the internal logic of their own nature, their yearning for a secularist and socialist political order. This yearning drew the Bees to Communism at one period in modern history, but it also survived the institutional death of Communism; though Communism was profoundly attractive to the Bees as long as it appeared viable, Communism as such was never the essence of the attraction. Its powerful appeal, during the naive phase of the Hive, was simply that the Soviet Union under Stalin looked like a winner -- a huge and altogether successful experiment in "building a new society" on progressive lines. It was also frightening, and during the 1930s, dubbed "the Red Decade" by Eugene Lyons (in his scathingly witty book of that title), it wielded incalculable power even in this country. Such people, Lyons wrote, "were drawn to the Great Experiment by its magnitude and seeming strength. Under the guise of a nobly selfless dedication they were, in fact, identifying themselves with Power." In fact, the Communists and pro-Communists of the Red Decade were distinguished by their real and virtual allegiance to the Soviet Union and to Stalin himself. Though they may have thought of themselves as internationalists who transcended national loyalties, they actually transferred their patriotism to a specific foreign power, which they defended, justified, and celebrated at every turn. It seems almost unbelievably naive now, but the evidence Lyons amassed is undeniable. THE RED DECADE is packed with the insane eulogies to Stalin and Soviet Russia that gushed from American liberals in those days. A new civilization was being born ... Russians were enjoying unprecedented freedom and prosperity ... A new Renaissance was thriving ... Industrial production was booming ... All lies and fantasies -- the very opposite of the indescribably grim truth. The vast and cruel tyranny was claiming millions of lives, most of them due to a policy of forced famine; the survivors lived in utter poverty, due equally to tyranny and incompetence; art, culture, and intellectual life were being crushed, along with religion. Civilization itself was being murdered in Russia, with the vociferous approval of free men in the still-civilized countries to the West. A few honest visitors told the truth. But they were shouted down, drowned out, vilified by the organized Stalin apologists. These included not only party hacks, but prominent and often gifted writers, intellectuals, and opinion-makers: Lincoln Steffens, Louis Fischer, John Strachey, Maurice Hindus, Malcolm Cowley, Granville Hicks, Theodore Dreiser, Dashiell Hammett, Paul de Kruif, James Weldon Johnson, Archibald MacLeish, George Soule, Langston Hughes, George Seldes, Richard Wright, Newton Arvin, Van Wyck Brooks, Kenneth Burke, Erskine Caldwell, Dorothy Parker, S.J. Perelman, Irwin Shaw, Irving Stone, Vincent Sheean, Upton Sinclair, Carl Van Doren, Louis Untermeyer, William Carlos Williams, Lillian Hellman, Henry Roth, Max Lerner, Heywood Broun, Ring Lardner Jr., and Nathaniel West. All in all, an impressive roster. No wonder it took a bold man to defy the engineered consensus that Stalin and Communism were the wave of the future, the harbingers of universal human destiny. Who could suppose that so many leading intellectuals were prostituting their minds for the sake of a single foreign tyrant? They seemed to speak for enlightenment itself. It's easy to suppose, now, that Communism was a minor part of American life in the Thirties. We have all been taught that McCarthy Era hysteria grossly magnified the reality. It didn't. Through his iron (though hidden) control of sycophantic intellectuals, labor unions, and other forces, Stalin wielded enormous power over millions of Americans, most of whom had no suspicion of his reach, or of his sinister influence over their opinion leaders. Stalin *was* Communism. Or rather, Communism became whatever Stalin said it was. Indifferent to theory, contemptuous of abstractions (and intellectuals), he had a crude and undistracted appreciation of power: how to get it, how to wield it, how to keep it. His method was simple: terror. He murdered those who resisted him; he also murdered those who assisted him, lest they acquire some claim on him. His ruthlessness was felt through his whole global network, and was emulated by his cadres abroad. Where murder wasn't possible, character assassination would do. The most severe punishments were meted out to defectors, and the dread of Stalin's (or his underlings') revenge did wonders for party cohesion. "Our own American Popular Front," Lyons wrote, "though never officially in power as it was in France and for a brief period in Spain, penetrated, in various degrees, the labor movement, education, the churches, college and non-college youth movements, the theater, movies, the arts, publishing in all its branches; it bored deep into the Federal Government and in many communities also into local government; it obtained a stranglehold on great sectors of national and local relief setups and made-work projects through domination of the Workers Alliance, capture of key jobs, and other stratagems. At its highest point -- roughly about 1938 -- the incredible revolution of the Red Decade had mobilized the conscious or the starry-eyed, innocent collaboration of thousands of influential American *educators, social workers, clergymen, New Deal officials, youth leaders, Negro and other racial spokesmen, Social Registerites, novelists, Hollywood stars, script writers, and directors, trade-union chiefs, men and women of abnormal wealth* [my emphasis]. Its echoes could be heard in the most unexpected places, including the supposed citadels of conservatism and respectability." Apart from its omission of journalists, this is a pretty fair catalogue of the constituent Bees of today's Hive. Of course time has added some new categories: feminists, homosexuals, environmentalists, and the like. Lyons added that "the complex communist United Front tinctured every department of American life while it lasted and has left its color indelibly on the mind and moral character of the country. Our labor movement, politics, arts, culture, and vocabulary still carry its imprint." If the Hive is spontaneous, the Red Decade *was* conspiratorial. Stalin and his helpers were able to manipulate "a horde of part-time pseudo-rebels who [had] neither courage nor convictions, but only a muddy emotionalism and a mental fog which made them an easy prey for the arbiters of a political racket." The dreaded charge of "red-baiting" (the forerunner of "McCarthyism," but far more deadly) was enough to cow into silence most criticism of Soviet Communism. And of Stalin himself. Anti-Communists risked, and often received, ostracism, vicious slander, and personal harassment. It was unnerving even to those few who had the nerve and stature to withstand it; and it was especially effective in deterring the far more numerous weak and timid souls from following their example. Lyons's book is a shocking reminder of how powerfully Communism gripped American public opinion, through publishing, entertainment, the labor movement, and higher education. Today Communism is dead -- and yet it isn't. The power that was once concentrated in a few Red hands is now diffused among countless others, but, though it doesn't exactly terrorize, it still intimidates. As Charles Peguy presciently put it nearly a century ago, "We shall never know how many acts of cowardice have been motivated by the fear of seeming not sufficiently progressive." During the Red Decade, Soviet apologists deemed old scruples out of place when measuring the Soviet achievement. "On the contrary," as Lyons observed, "the more distasteful the chore, the greater the credit." Repression, purge, forced famine were alternately denied and defended. The ten years of the Red Decade were "the years of the apotheosis of Stalin. The Revolution had been reduced to one man; Marxism, Soviet style, was just another name for the whims and blunders of one man; the Communist International and all its myriad appendages were literally nothing more than his private racket." Today's Hive is thoroughly decentralized. Yet it still maintains its own highly effective discipline. It has refined ideology into a sort of etiquette. "Progressive" opinion enjoys the aura of politesse; whereas "reactionary" views are felt to be ignorant and boorish. The New Deal proved hospitable to Communist infiltration. Franklin Roosevelt, though sometimes wary of open association, praised Stalin's 1936 constitution -- sufficient proof, by the way, that he had no grasp whatever of the U.S. Constitution. Joseph Davies, his ambassador to Moscow, wrote a famously fatuous book, MISSION TO MOSCOW, in praise of Stalin's utopia. Such cabinet officers as Frances Perkins (who, Lyons wrote, "seems to live in dread of criticism from the Left"), Harold Ickes, and Henry Wallace were always ready to lend their names and persons to Communist-front groups. As for Eleanor Roosevelt, Lyons captures her essence: "The First Lady of the land became almost standard equipment in setting up any new Innocents' Club or in bolstering the prestige of an old one; her sympathetic heart, her social-worker enthusiasm and ideological naivete made her a perfect subject for communist hoaxes.... In the inner circle of activists, I was told, she was regarded as one of the party's most valuable assets." One precious detail emerged long after Lyons's book was published: Mrs. Roosevelt, attending a diplomatic function, insisted on being escorted by Alger Hiss. Stalin could count on his cadres, fellow-travelers, and dupes to follow every twist and reverse in his party line, but he finally demanded too much even of the most gullible. He destroyed his own Popular Front when he made his pact with Germany in 1939 and joined the rape of Poland. At that point even many hard-core Communists, hating Hitler even more than they loved Stalin, at last broke away in disgust. From that moment, mechanical pro-Communism in America was a thing of the past. The Soviet Union lost nearly all its American loyalists. Many of them would still pine for an "ideal" Communism, and continued to regard Soviet Russia as vaguely progressive, but the old thrill was gone forever. During World War II Stalin enjoyed a temporary reconciliation with American liberal opinion; through no fault of his own, Soviet Russia was invaded by its German allies (as Lyons had predicted) in June 1941, and in December the United States entered the war on Stalin's side. U.S. Government propaganda lied to the American public about its "Russian friends" as shamelessly as the Communists and fellow-travelers had lied during the Red Decade. At the war's end, the fruits of victory in Central Europe were too sweet for Stalin to bother hiding his true colors, and American illusions were no longer possible. Today the liberals have run out of utopias. Russia is Russia again, having renounced the Red dream after terror devolved into shabbiness; China, though semi- Commie, can be nobody's ideal; Cuba is both brutal and squalid. Even Sweden has lost its charm. The Hive no longer believes in socialism, though it keeps moving spasmodically toward it out of old habits. The victory of market capitalism is too clear, and planned economies have proved embarrassing. The Bees have to settle for keeping the welfare state -- also semi- disreputable -- and making hay on abortion, sodomy, environmentalism, smoking, whatever promises to allow some incremental government growth. During the impeachment battle they defended Bill Clinton with the same solidarity with which the old Left defended Stalin, but it wasn't really the same. Stalin was, after all, a far more inspirational figure. But the residue of the Red Decade is still with us, just as Lyons said sixty years ago. The Hive bears traces of its ancestry. It still believes reflexively in the state, vilifies its opponents, and, above all, keeps its gains. It practices not only a "politics of personal destruction," but a politics of *general* destruction, in which all social relations are determined by force. It believes in power and nothing else. Having said all that, I think the strongest resemblance between the old Left and the Hive lies in their shared hatred of human individuality. To become a Bee in this Hive is to surrender, voluntarily and eagerly, your own personality; to submerge the self in a collectivity; to prefer the buzzing cliche of the group to individualized thought and expression; to take satisfaction in belonging, and conforming, to a powerful mass, while punishing others for failure to conform. This is not only a political but a spiritual condition. It was true of the Stalinists, and it's true of the Hive. All the names have changed since the Thirties, yet you get the eerie feeling that the old Stalinists and today's Bees are somehow *the same people.* The similarity to an insect colony -- where the individual exists only functionally, being both indistinguishable from and interchangeable with its fellows -- is not superficial. It's of the essence. To be an insect is to be relieved of the burden of having a soul of your own. For the Record (page 6) (Material deleted from the print version for reasons of space is contained in square brackets [thus].) Nothing, it seems, can dispel the notion that Pope Pius XII maintained a "shameful silence" about the persecution of Jews during World War II. But Ralph McInerny, in his book THE DEFAMATION OF PIUS XII, quotes what Jews, prominent and otherwise, were saying at the time. "Only the Catholic Church protested against the Hitlerian onslaught on liberty," said Albert Einstein in 1940. In 1942 London's JEWISH CHRONICLE remarked: "A word of sincere and earnest appreciation is due from Jews to the Vatican for its intervention in Berlin and Vichy on behalf of their tortured co-religionists in France.... [It was a step urged, to their honor, by a number of Catholics, but for which we may be sure the Holy Father himself, with his intense humanity and his clear sighted understanding of the true and deadly implications of the assaults on the Jewish people, needed no prompting.]" Dr. Alexander Shafran, chief rabbi of Romania, wrote in 1944: "In these hard times our thoughts turn more than ever with respectful gratitude to the Sovereign Pontiff, who has done so much for Jews in general.... In our worst hours of trial, the generous aid and noble support of the Holy See ... has been decisive. It is not easy to find the proper words to express the relief and solace which the magnanimous gesture of the Supreme Pontiff has given us, in offering a large subsidy in order to alleviate the sufferings of the deported Jews. Roumanian Jewry will never forget these facts of historical importance." After the Allies liberated Rome in 1944, a Jewish Brigade Group said in its BULLETIN: "To the everlasting glory of the people of Rome and the Roman Catholic Church we can state that the fate of the Jews was alleviated by their truly Christian offers of assistance and shelter. Even now, many still remain in the religious homes and houses which opened their doors to protect them from deportation to certain death." One survivor, quoted in a Hebrew daily in Israel, said: "If we have been rescued, if Jews are still alive in Rome, come with us and thank the Pope in the Vatican." A committee of the American Jewish Welfare Board, wrote to Pius himself: "We have received reports from our military chaplains in Italy of the aid and protection to Italian Jews by the Vatican, priests, and church institutions during the Nazi occupation of the country. We are deeply moved by this extraordinary display of Christian love -- the more so as we know the risk incurred by those who afforded shelter to Jews.... From the bottom of our hearts we send you the assurances of undying gratitude." The elders of one liberated camp went to Rome and presented Pius with a letter: "Now that the victorious Allied troops have broken our chains and liberated us from captivity and danger, may we, the Jewish internees of Ferramonti, be permitted to express our deepest and devoted thanks for the comfort and help which Your Holiness deigned to grant us with fatherly concern and infinite kindness throughout our years of internment and persecution.... In doing so Your Holiness has as the first and highest authority on earth fearlessly raised his universally respected voice, in the face of our powerful enemies, in order to defend openly our rights to the dignity of man.... When we were threatened with deportation to Poland in 1942, Your Holiness extended his fatherly hand to protect us, and stopped the transfer of the Jews interned in Italy, thereby saving us from almost certain death. With deep confidence and hope that the work of Your Holiness may be crowned with further success, we beg to express our heartfelt thanks while we pray to the Almighty: May Your Holiness reign for many years on this Holy See and exert your beneficent influence over the destiny of the nations." A few months later the World Jewish Congress sent a telegram to the Holy See thanking it for its protection "under difficult conditions to the persecuted Jews in German dominated Hungary." The chief rabbi of Jerusalem, Isaac Herzog, said: "I thank the Pope and the Church from the bottom of my heart for all the help they have afforded." Moshe Sharett, a leading Zionist, summed up his personal interview with Pius: "I told him that my first duty was to thank him, and through him, the Catholic Church, on behalf of the Jewish public, for all they had done in the various countries to rescue Jews, to save children, and Jews in general. We are deeply grateful to the Catholic Church for what she did in those countries to help save our brothers." Dr. Leon Kubowitzky of the World Jewish Council offered a large monetary donation to the Vatican "in recognition of the work of the Holy See in rescuing Jews from Fascist and Nazi persecutions." Raffaele Cantoni of Italy's Jewish Welfare Committee said: "The Catholic Church and the papacy have given proof that they have saved as many Jews as they could." These noble and moving words require little comment. I record them here for the honor of Pius, the Catholic Church, and the good men who uttered them. NUGGETS CRUEL AND UNUSUAL: The Justice Department reports a sharp decline in AIDS-related deaths in prisons -- only 242 in 1999, down from a peak of 1010 in 1995, but HIV infections in prisons are increasing. Homosexual rape, a common feature of life behind bars, is ugly enough; but now it threatens to become lethal. You don't have to be a bleeding-heart reformer to ask why a criminal conviction should entail the risk of death. (page 9) SECULARISM IN ONE LESSON: The separation of church and state seems to mean chiefly that the Ten Commandments don't apply to the government -- particularly those forbidding killing, stealing, and coveting. (page 10) Exclusive to the electronic version: LATE HIT: New disclosures from Russia inform us that Joseph Stalin had an illegitimate son by a 14-year-old girl. Why are we only learning this *now?* What Uncle Joe did in his private life was his own business, as long as it didn't interfere with his performance of his public duties. THE FASHIONABLE CONSCIENCE: Justice Sandra Day O'Connor intimates that she has qualms about the death penalty: "If statistics are any indication, the system may well be allowing some innocent defendants to be executed." Very true, but why are the workings of the "system," at the state level, the business of the federal judiciary? And by the way, why isn't Justice O'Connor troubled that the system allows innocent babies to be aborted? REPRINTED COLUMNS (pages 7-12) * The Age of the Misfit (June 7, 2001) http://www.sobran.com/columns/010607.shtml * The Judiciary and the Rule of Law (June 12, 2001) http://www.sobran.com/columns/010612.shtml * Bowdlerizing C.S. Lewis (June 19, 2001) http://www.sobran.com/columns/010619.shtml * Baseball's Knight (June 26, 2001) http://www.sobran.com/columns/010626.shtml * In the Name of "Civil Liberties" (June 28, 2001) http://www.sobran.com/columns/010628.shtml * John Locke in the Middle East (July 3, 2001) http://www.sobran.com/columns/010703.shtml ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ All articles are written by Joe Sobran You may forward this newsletter if you include the following subscription and copyright information: Subscribe to the Sobran E-Package. See http://www.sobran.com/e-mail.shtml or http://www.griffnews.com for details and samples or call 800-513-5053. Copyright (c) 2001 by The Vere Company. All rights reserved. Distributed by the Griffin Internet Syndicate www.griffnews.com with permission. [ENDS]