The Reactionary Utopian
March 16, 2006
A QUAGMIRE OF IDEAS
by Joe Sobran
President Bush says we are not only in a war of
arms, but "a war of ideas." And, as I understand it, he
figures he's just the man to lead the free world into
intellectual combat.
Apart from "democracy," the president's idee du jour
is that our biggest challenge comes from Iran, whose
current leader, a Mr. Ahmadinejad, has his own arsenal of
ideas. He says that the state of Israel should be wiped
off the map and that the Holocaust didn't happen, for
example. Of course politicians will say anything to get
elected, but Bush won't stand idly by while Ahmadinejad
slips dangerous ideas to al-Qaeda and other terrorist
groups. The danger to the world is that the War of Ideas
will escalate and spread beyond the Middle East.
In wartime, the president, under our Constitution,
is not only our chief executive but the commander in
chief of our ideas. In this respect, I have to wonder if
Bush is quite up to the job. At one time, I thought he
might be at least approximately conservative, in a
practical sense. No longer.
Frankly, I've been disappointed in Bush. It's always
somewhat disappointing when a guy you took for a
reasonably functional numbskull turns out to be, in fact,
an utterly hapless imbecile. If this is a war of ideas,
we're in for a real quagmire.
Now Bush is reaffirming one of his pet ideas, the
idea of preemptive warfare, which he believes has been
a stunning success in Iraq. Since he is fond of World
War II analogies, he ought to ponder one of its obvious
lessons: unintended consequences.
The Japanese preemptive strike on Pearl Harbor,
however well-intentioned, failed to prevent Franklin D.
Roosevelt from acquiring weapons of mass destruction. On
the contrary, he developed them anyway -- and he and his
successor used them on Tokyo and Hiroshima. If Bush is
contemplating a sneak attack on Iran, he might bear this
precedent in mind.
Americans have notoriously short attention spans,
but other nations have long memories. This week the Ides
of March passed unnoticed in this country, but in Ireland
it revived, as always, an ancient grudge: Irishmen
bitterly remember it as the date on which Brutus and his
ilk completely spoiled all Julius Caesar's plans for
St. Patrick's Day. Brutus later lamely explained that the
hit on Caesar was a preemptive strike to save the
Republic, but it backfired and resulted in civil war,
then in the Roman Empire, headed by rulers every bit as
goofy as Bush.
It can't be repeated often enough: War always brings
unintended consequences. Nobody foresaw that the Iraq war
would lead to Bush's claim of intellectual leadership. If
we had, there might have been more resistance at the
beginning, even from conservatives.
This war has taken a terrible toll on journalists.
Some have been killed, and those who survived have had to
learn to spell a lot of weird names, such as
"Ahmadinejad." Many of us -- and I think I speak for
everyone -- have a hard enough time spelling
"Condoleezza."
Miss Rice, the mushroom cloud lady, is now being
touted as a possible successor to Bush in 2008. Though
she says she has no plans to seek the presidency, some
Republicans think she would be the ideal candidate to
counter the Democrats' favorite at the moment, Hillary
Clinton. No doubt this would make for an extremely
exciting campaign, and whoever won we would have a
historic first: a woman president.
Nobody could complain that there wasn't "a dime's
worth of difference" between the two candidates. The
alternatives would be dramatic. The voters would have to
choose between a black spinster and an old white woman
married to Bill Clinton. The head spins. Both, of course,
would continue the war in Iraq and, probably, Iran.
If elected, Rice could be expected to continue
Bush's other policies, programs, and aspirations, such as
putting a man on Mars, weather permitting (the
post-Katrina proviso). But it wouldn't necessarily have
to be a man; it could be a minority woman.
As for the War of Ideas, meanwhile, we may never
know when we have won it. There would seem to be no
middle ground between Bush and Ahmadinejad, and both are
very determined men. Maybe the best we can hope for is a
costly stalemate.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Read this column on-line at
"http://www.sobran.com/columns/2006/060316.shtml".
Copyright (c) 2006 by the Griffin Internet Syndicate,
www.griffnews.com. This column may not be published in
print or Internet publications without express permission
of Griffin Internet Syndicate. You may forward it to
interested individuals if you use this entire page,
including the following disclaimer:
"SOBRAN'S and Joe Sobran's columns are available
by subscription. For details and samples, see
http://www.sobran.com/e-mail.shtml, write
PR@griffnews.com, or call 800-513-5053."